'The Billionaire's Vinegar' by Benjamin Wallace: Inside the world of wine forgery
12:00 AM CDT on Sunday, July 13, 2008
The Billionaire's Vinegar is a cautionary tale: Money will make you stupid.
Benjamin Wallace takes us on a tour of the ridiculously rich, the underworld of wine forgery and a Founding Father's great passion. We begin in the august auction rooms of Christie's in London, where a Forbes scion in 1985 pays a record $156,000 for a bottle of 1787 Chateau Lafite Bordeaux believed to have been owned by Thomas Jefferson.
For nearly 300 pages, Mr. Wallace then ably takes us on a tour of how wine moved beyond agricultural foodstuff to pricey collectible coveted by the world's wealthy.
Enthusiastic to show off their good taste, not to mention their fat wallets, a small group of collectors worldwide threw extravagant "mega-tastings" with dozens of wines, many of them vintages that spanned centuries.
The most riveting part of the story is the mystery of Hardy Rodenstock, former rock band manager turned wine whisperer. The German had a knack for finding the rarest of vintages, fetching extraordinary prices from eager collectors.
Afraid of being cut out of Mr. Rodenstock's clique, financiers, industrialists and scientists checked common sense at the door. (North Texas has a cameo in Fort Worth neurosurgeon Marvin Overton III, a wine collector who also hosted some of the extravagant tastings.)
Even the so-called experts turned a blind eye to the apparent chicanery. Christie's Michael Broadbent created modern wine auctions with the liquid treasure he unearthed from Britain's castle cellars. But he, too, was seduced by Mr. Rodenstock and went to extreme lengths to give the German credibility as more and more collectors began to doubt him.
All in all, Mr. Wallace nicely peels back the covers of a world most of us will never see. The book takes on a C.S.I. flair in the chapters dealing with the extreme methods forgers employed to create their goods, and the complex systems scientists have devised to root out the fakes. And the chapters on Jefferson offer a nontraditional view of the third president through his love of wine.
The book's ending is lacking and feels rushed. Though the book suggests that Mr. Rodenstock was a fraud, hawking fake vintages, there's no definitive conclusion, which is unsatisfying.
On the one hand, you want to see justice served. On the other, perhaps his wealthy targets simply got what they deserved.
The Mystery of the World's Most Expensive Bottle of Wine
Benjamin Wallace
(Crown, $24.95)
Author Jewell Parker Rhodes shares grandma's wisdom at 'Tulisoma' book fair
Co-author of '100 Things to Do Before You Die' dead at 47
'Stand the Storm' by Breena Clarke:
'Rose Bowl Dreams' by Adam Jones: God exists, and he's a Longhorns fan
Authors take entertaining and educational looks at what we don't know about Arabs and Islam
Most Popular Stories
Get feedFoods vie for best of fried title at State Fair of Texas
Employees: 'Hierarchy of hotness' rules at Abercrombie & Fitch
Report: Dallas-Fort Worth has strongest job market in U.S.
Dallas Cowboys crack down on Texas Stadium tailgating
Employees say Abercrombie & Fitch is judging workers based on looks
